Order Listing   Title Listing   Comic Box Listings   Group Listings   Story Arc Listings   Character Listings
CMRO Order Header
Main Reading Order
Core Reading Order
Ultimate Reading Order
Golden Age Reading Order
Expanded Reading Order
All Reading Orders
Comments Header
 

Comments from Newest to Oldest

 
View By: 10 25 50 100 250    
Sort By: votes newest
  
Russ Says:
Avengers #145 (v1) : I'm with everybody else on the deadline/continuity issues, so I won't re-hash that. I'm also with everyone else about the quality of this issue as a stand-alone; I'll comment about that alone.

Tony Isabella has a barn burner going here. He's got a nice little suspenseful arc with Cap in a coma and the others misdirected on where the real threat lies. This one could have a fair-sized body count before it's over (if you believe the Assassin about the poison within the gang's masks, and the tainted money paid to the old woman). And we get some stronger hints on what Cap means to the other Avengers, leading to some pretty good character development; something you don't usually see in this title, at least not at this level. That's something I'd have expected from Englehart, especially since he wrote arguably the best Cap stories so far in the Order.

I'm giving this 4 stars in spite of the continuity break. This is way above and beyond typical filler, and I can't penalize the story for what it is. But I do hope they offer a better explanation on how this does fit into continuity.
 
Marvel Comments
 
jennychan Says:
Journey into Mystery #99a (v1) : Just wish Stan would lay off the super-wordy captions and let the artwork explain the scene.

I liked Mr. Hyde in the 1980s and early 1990s, so interesting to see his debut.
 
Marvel Comments
 
TStarnes Says:
Fantastic Four #21 (v1) : Keep an eye on the expanded order. When it reaches this point it merges the main order with the WWII order (and all the others), giving you how to read this comic in combination with the ones in other orders.
 
Marvel Comments
 
1
RobinHoodMtl Says:
Amazing Spider-Man #38 (v1) :
  • That's my line – "I haven't been able to find one good secretary since she walked out of here! They all want coffee breaks... pension funds... profit sharing...!" (J. J. Jameson)

  • That's my line too – "Actually, I've never met a modest costumed scrapper before! Usually, they start off by saying 'Nobody can defeat the Purple Pantywaist!', or 'You fool! Don't you realize you've no chance against the Human Windshield Wiper!'" (Spider-Man)

  • Joe Smith! I don't think they were able to find a more common name than that!

  • Fun scene with the students protesting against... well, practically nothing! One more star for that!

  • Unlike the Doctor Strange series, we cannot say that Ditko left this one with a fanfare, giving us an average filler. Things must have gone pretty bad with Stan if he didn't bother to make a decent cover or even a splash page. And unlike the other series, I cannot say that I'm disappointed that someone else takes over the art for Spider-Man. True, Ditko was good at drawing Spider-Man in action scenes and wrote the best plots in the MU at this time. But I will surely not miss the way he was drawing regular people.

  • Looking at the smilin' dummy at the end and how Spider-Man punches him got me wondering if this was not Ditko's subtle attempt to get back at Stan. The dummy does bear more resemblance with young Smilin' Stan than with Ned Leeds, doesn't it?

  • Also, ain't that a shame, or at least ironic, that Ditko left the series without ever drawing Mary-Jane's face?

  • I was a bit disappointed with this one. I was hoping that Ditko's last Silver Age story with Marvel would be more memorable, but it really is not. Sorry, but 3 stars are all I can give.
 
Marvel Comments
 
logan49 Says:
Fantastic Four #5 (v1) : DOOOOOOOM!!!
 
Marvel Comments
 
JonahBlack Says:
Captain America #147 (v1) : This was better, or at least more readable, than last issue. The mastermind being Kingpin doesn't make a lot of sense, but I concede that I may be colored by later portrayals of the kingpin.
 
Marvel Comments
 
JonahBlack Says:
Captain America #146 (v1) : The plot and pacing of the issue are...okay... but the dialog is unreadable. There are worse issues in the order, but this one was an unpleasant chore to get through.

I did like the Femme Force being more useful, though.
 
Marvel Comments
 
jemsmck Says:
Champ Comics #19a : How would you not know if someone got in your car while you were in it?
 
Marvel Comments
 
Hoshizora Says:
Peter Parker, The Spectacular... : This is the first comic I've read with an appearance by Punisher or Kingpin, and even I can tell something is wildly off with the characters.
 
Marvel Comments
 
jemsmck Says:
All-Winners Comics #4a (v1) : Love the insults. Die Liberty Lovers!
 
Marvel Comments
 
bharbeke Says:
Amazing Spider-Man #691 (v1) : Great cover and issue!
 
Marvel Comments
 
bill_the_cat Says:
X-Men #8 (v1) : A possible explanation for why Beast didn't explain himself: Sometimes it is easier for scary-smart people to implement their plans than it is for them to explain them to us mere mortals. It seems to be almost physically painful for them to dumb down their explanation enough for the rest of us to understand and can take a lot of time. Easier for them to say, "trust me this will work." This could be an excuse for the Beast and Reed at times. However both of them love to talk and show off their intelligence so this isn't a perfect explanation.
 
Marvel Comments
 
skywalker3880 Says:
Defenders #42 (v1) : In the time between Val's jail stint and now, she's searched every city dump to recover her old outfit that the police threw away. Hulk 207 ended so well with an emotional burden on Hulk but let's ignore that too.
Still, interested to see where this goes despite having Egghead show back up.
 
Marvel Comments
 
jemsmck Says:
Young Allies #3a (v1) : The art is much better in this issue than in previous issues. The beautiful two-page spread was bay far one of the best shots in the era to date. Not a fan of how the Japanese were literally portrayed as monsters with claws and filed pointed teeth. The story itself is just average with the standard logic issues but otherwise not a bad issue.
 
Marvel Comments
 
metasynthie Says:
The Spectacular Spider-Man #190... : With all the mind-games on Peter, Liz and Normie, Harry comes across much scarier than his father did! Quite an accomplishment considering the long shadow of the original Green Goblin.
 
Marvel Comments
 
metasynthie Says:
The Spectacular Spider-Man #189a... : Cycle of abuse, illustrated and magnified.
 
Marvel Comments
 
bill_the_cat Says:
Tales to Astonish #63a (v1) : I'm getting thrown out a door...wheeeeee. I don't see this bear trap on a bare floor in a well lit room. Last time I punched a hole in an unfamiliar ceiling to find wires it took me several tries to get them...then I realized how much easier it would have been to flip the switch.
 
Marvel Comments
 
jgauthie001 Says:
Daredevil #90 (v1) :
 
Marvel Comments
 
gmonkey Says:
Excalibur #56 (v1) : Alan Davis should be more celebrated.
 
Marvel Comments
 
Anansi2010 Says:
Bloodstone #1 : Subtle character design.
 
Marvel Comments
 
stiffmeyster Says:
Fantastic Four #21 (v1) : I feel as cheated as Anonymous up here in the comments.
Man I read every $@%#%^ issue in the order and now turns out that I haven't been doing it right?
Where these Sgt. Fury stories came from? What do I do now? Where am I?
This issue has just ruined my life.
 
Marvel Comments
 
skalchemist Says:
Doctor Strange: Sorcerer Supreme... : The death itself was at least heroic it's the "no time to grieve" thing that makes me mad
 
Marvel Comments
 
grayrender Says:
Captain America #306 (v1) : Crap. Just crap.

Braddock, naked and unarmed, is running through a medeival armory on his way to a brawl and fails to pick up narry a morningstar as a souvenir. This, and everything else about rhus dreck, led me to the first Cap 1-star I've seen a while.
 
Marvel Comments
 
jwerth Says:
Power Man and Iron Fist #57 (v1) : Were they not paying von Eeden enough to draw full panels? There were so many panels with blank backgrounds that it really took something away from this issue. Good interactions between Luke and Danny, but I wish Colleen and Misty were more than just a sobbing mess, that didn’t seem at all true to character.
 
Marvel Comments
 
Katryn Says:
Monsters Unleashed #7b (v1) : This would have actually been a better story if Jack did know that Coker was also a werewolf for it. But it's still better than most of the other Werewolf stories.
 
Marvel Comments
 
DarianRogue Says:
Marvel Mystery Comics #7c : I am SO pumped.
 
Marvel Comments
 
Katryn Says:
Monsters Unleashed #6b (v1) : This is probably the best Werewolf story I've read in a long time, definitely helped by the fact that he actually remembered that it was a full moon and went elsewhere for the night.
 
Marvel Comments
 
metasynthie Says:
The Spectacular Spider-Man #187... : This is a much better and more textured conclusion to the story of Nathan Lubensky.
 
Marvel Comments
 
metasynthie Says:
Darkhawk #15 : This arc makes Darkhawk feel like a more well-fleshed character, with motivations and troubles beyond "excited teen trying to figure out how to be a superhero." At the same time, it feels very much cast in the mold of Spider-Man -- tragic death of male parental figure makes him serious about doing good, while keeping the secret from his female parental figure, and he even swings around (on a cable) and fights a bunch of Spider-Man villains, at least in this arc. Next step: differentiate from the most popular hero, maybe?
 
Marvel Comments
 
wcharrison355 Says:
Fantastic Four #243 (v1) : Well, they did say he was shrinking in the interior, so maybe that explains it.
 
Marvel Comments
 
blueballs9 Says:
Captain America #161 (v1) : The setup kind of bugs me. Any self respecting villain would have just slit their throats and dumped them in a ditch instead of playing games.
 
Marvel Comments
 
wcharrison355 Says:
Fantastic Four #243 (v1) : Really well done. Great Byrne art, and he really humanizes Galactus, making it possible to be sympathetic to him. I remember reading this when it was out, though, and thinking Cap and Reed were crazy in trying to save him, since they would surely doom millions more if he lived.
 
Marvel Comments
 
wcharrison355 Says:
Ghost Rider #69 (v2) : Strange seeing the demon in a red and yellow costume. Not that bad, although the moral could instead be for young, pretty girls to not be so loose or they might end up thrown from a car and almost run over by runaway construction vehicles.
 
Marvel Comments
 
Russ Says:
Avengers #144 (v1) : That's how Patsy became Hellcat? Cap saying "Here, put this on"? No ideas on how Roxxon or Brand got a hold of the costume in the first place, or who it was that wore it? Cap, I sure hope you could tell if that was washed first *shudder*

And yeah, Roxxon is on a completely different level of threat if they can transport people across alternate universes. Somehow this arc just kind of turned ridiculous, and not in a good way.

2 stars. Still holding out hope that Englehart knew what he was doing. And George Perez's artwork is always a treat.
 
Marvel Comments
 
RobinHoodMtl Says:
Marvel Mystery Comics #58c : That's my line – "Wait! You can't strike a woman!" "Why not? I'm a woman too!" (Black Widow and Miss America)
 
Marvel Comments
 
RobinHoodMtl Says:
Marvel Mystery Comics #58b : They could fit a the whole tribe on their ceremonial boat? Well, given they are actually cannibals on a small isolate island, they probably ate each other off, but still...
 
Marvel Comments
 
Vancelot Says:
Uncanny X-Men #213 (v1) : It was good. I rounded up to 4 stars, but it feels like a 3.5 star story.
 
Marvel Comments
 
mormegil4 Says:
Captain America #113 (v1) : The art and coherent storyline made this 5 stars from for me. Vision and Thor being affected by the gas brought me out of the moment and I hate the fact that he has a secret identity again. But the art was so good.

This is Steranko's best issue yet.
 
Marvel Comments
 
Russ Says:
Avengers #143 (v1) : You'd think Kang would've learned by now that the last thing he'd want to try to do is out-power Thor. Sure, he's got 41st century know-how on his side, but he's up against a god. Dude, there's only outcome in a case like that and it generally doesn't favor you.

Not impressed with Moondragon during this storyline. She sees to fancy herself a god but really wasn't of much use here except to make the cowboys do double-takes at her bald head.

3 stars. Fun little story overall. If it weren't for that, I'd be saying it's taken two issues too long for the other Avengers to free themselves from Brand Corporation's trap.
 
Marvel Comments
 
jemsmck Says:
The Human Torch #7a : The great full page spread on the secret base almost makes up for the blatant racism.
 
Marvel Comments
 
1
mormegil4 Says:
Incredible Hulk #115 (v1) : I love the speed suit reference
 
Marvel Comments
 
2
Locust75 Says:
Giant-Size Defenders #1 : I was really hoping Clea and Valkyrie would've had a good ol' fashioned pillow fight!!!

'Nuff Said - "--Let the magicks in my fingers enter your very ego..."-Clea to Valkyrie...
 
Marvel Comments
 
mormegil4 Says:
Captain America #112 (v1) : I thought the art for this was great. Especially the splash on page 14.
 
Marvel Comments
 
2
Locust75 Says:
Defenders #12 (v1) : I don't know, I always had a soft spot for the big ol' fluff ball! I agree with Russ, they really don't know what to do with Xemnu yet. He should've had no problem mentally stopping the Hulk?!

'Nuff Said - "Well, Hulk hates you back--"-Hulkster
 
Marvel Comments
 
RobinHoodMtl Says:
Kid Komics #6b : Funny how the Destroyer just puts on some civilian clothes over his costume and suddenly, he assumes that he looks just any other regular guy, regardless of the mask.
 
Marvel Comments
 
2
Locust75 Says:
Marvel Two-in-One #1 : I never knew that Marvel Two-On-One was previously Marvel Feature! Anyway we know the real Molecule Man will return someday. I agree with the Thing at the end, it's a baton, not a wand!

'Nuff Said - "My hand--firm--strong--"-Son of the Molecule Man
 
Marvel Comments
 
1
Locust75 Says:
Marvel Feature #12 (v1) : I fell this would've been a better story set in the 80's during the Thing's wrestling career. A tag team bout with Thanos as manager of the Blood Brothers. I can see him throwing chairs and holding Iron Man against the ropes! And have Mentor as the inept referee who can't control the match!

So the Blood Brothers are real space vampires?!

'Nuff Said - "--I wuz beginin' ta look forward ta some good licks--eh?"-Thing
 
Marvel Comments
 
edgar987 Says:
Fantastic Four #149 (v1) : I can’t believe the ff are getting consistent 2s. How the mighty have fallen! Awful.
 
Marvel Comments
 
metsguy Says:
Defenders #6 (v1) : It’s a shame Cyrus Black has only three more appearances in the Order.
 
Marvel Comments
 
Russ Says:
Avengers #142 (v1) : Slap on some chaps, grab yer Stetson, and travel back to the Old West with....the Avengers? I liked how Hawkeye got here and how well he fit in. Considering all the problems he's had in the present, it wouldn't have surprised me if he stayed in the past. It'd be pretty much the same reason the Black Knight had; you know, the guy he went after in the first place. Ironic, isn't it?

And if I remember correctly, he was originally called the Ghost Rider, but they changed his name to Night Rider/Phantom Rider so as not to cause any confusion with the modern day Ghost Rider, Johnny Blaze. Like it makes a difference if that's true; we have two Human Torches and two Visions, right?

3 stars. I don't really think I want to read the western heroes either, but this arc is great fun so far.
 
Marvel Comments
 
Sort By: votes newest
  
 
 
CMRO Sidebar
CMRO Sidebar Search Top

CMRO Sidebar Support Us

 

Shop at Amazon
 
Become a Patron of my writing
 
DC Comics Reading Order
Marvel Cinematic Universe Order
Star Wars Reading Order
Star Trek Reading Order
Doctor Who Order
CMRO Latest Badges Header
scatteredshowers0   The Trickster Badge
scatteredshowers0   Odins Blessing Badge
DrewDrawed   Center of the Universe Badge
DotC   The Stark Award Badge
chrob   Fly Like a Butterfly, Sting like a Bee Badge
chrob   Locutus Badge
imeco   New Blood Badge
PerlitaNegra   Agent 13 Badge
Krusty56   What Fourth Wall Badge
JonahBlack   G-Man Badge