Home Order List Forums Stats/Leader Comic News Login FAQs Podcasts Register
CMRO Menu Header
Marvel reading order menue bottom
Comic Ads
Comic Ads
Main 616 Order Main 616 Order Ultimate Order Ultimate Order    
Comic Ads
Comic Ads



 
Hero Initative Donate


Comic Blog Elite
Comics Detail top

126: Tales to Astonish #53 (v1)

"Trapped by the Porcupine! / When Wakes the Colossus!"
Comic Star RatingComic Star RatingComic Star RatingComic Star RatingComic Star Rating
 (2.03)
      20 comments
 
 
 
Editor-in-Chief:
Cover Artists:
Writers:
Stan Lee
Pencilers:
Dick Ayers
Inkers:
Colourists:
Letterers: Sam Rosen
Editors:
Cover Date: March 1964
Release Date: December 1963
Story Arc: -
Pages: 23
Cover Price: $0.12
Times Read: 204
Times Rated: 117
 
 Issue #52

Read Tales to Astonish Online
 Issue #54
 
   
 
Tales to Astonish #53 (v1)
Buy Tales to Astonish Online   Buy Essential Ant-Man, Volume 1 Online
 
FULL ORDER

Tales to Astonish #52 (v1)
Tales of Suspense #51
Tales to Astonish #53 (v1)
Fantastic Four #25 (v1)
Fantastic Four #26 (v1)
124: Tales to Asto...
#52 (v1)
125: Tales of Susp...
#51
 
127: Fantastic Fou...
#25 (v1)
128: Fantastic Fou...
#26 (v1)
Comic Ads
 
ISSUE BLURB

The inventive genius of Alex Gentry has returned as the Porcupine! After being thwarted by Ant-man in their last encounter by liquid cement, the Porcupine has a new plan to exact his revenge on our hero!

 
ISSUE NOTES
 
  • There are no notes for this issue.
 
Comic Ads Comic Ads
Comic Ads
CHARACTER APPEARANCES 
 
Main Characters
  Giant-Man
Giant-Man last appeared in Tales to Astonish #52 (v1). Giant-Man next appears in Fantastic Four #25 (v1).
     
  The Wasp
The Wasp last appeared in Tales to Astonish #52 (v1). The Wasp next appears in Fantastic Four #25 (v1).
     
Villains
  Porcupine
Porcupine last appeared in Tales to Astonish #48 (v1). Porcupine next appears in X-Men #22 (v1).
     
ISSUE REVIEW
 
There is no review of this issue.
 
 
ISSUE SYNOPSIS
 
There is not synopsis for this issue.
 
 
RECOMMENDING READING
 
  • There is no recommended reading for this issue.
 
COMMENTS
 
Marvel Comments
  thomassp74 Says:  
  2011-11-25 22:36:15  
  This issue really got on my nerves more than most for some reason.

Of course doing a flip will slow the descent of a falling man….if you went to the same school of physics as Wiley Coyote.

12 ft. tall and only 360 lb.? He’d be skin and bones.

Look in the phone book for a Giant Man and Wasp fanclub? Why didn’t I think of that?

“My jets propel me in short spurts…but I have to use my ingenuity in order to stop! Which is what I’m doing now!” I wonder how many kids during the Marvel Age of Comics developed psychological issues from talking to themselves.

Did Ant Man just yell on a crowded sidewalk that Porcupine was “getting away with Jan?” For a supposed super genius, he doesn’t seem to get this whole secret identity thing.

“You will remain a prisoner here until you reveal Giant Man’s true identity to me.” But I’m not worried about removing your mask, because what use could discovering the identity of his partner be to me? You’re an evil mastermind there Porky.

Why would Porky need that elaborate plan to find Giant Man? He was just at his loft, with a bunch of freaking kids, earlier in the issue.

Hank: “Jan, fly to safety!” Jan: “Don’t count on me for help!” Obviously girls are totally useless to comic book fans. What would we ever need them for? ;)

Hank couldn’t shrink because it would shatter his ankle, and then a few pages later he runs on his fractured ankle, shrinks, and then enlarges with no damage.

I almost gave this issue two stars just because I like Porcupine, but I couldn’t do it.
 
 
4
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  TStarnes Says:  
  2011-11-26 01:12:34  
  You like Porcupine.....really?  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  thomassp74 Says:  
  2011-11-26 09:44:59  
  For some reason I actually kind of do. I think it's because he looks so radically different from all the other heroes and villains. It kind of reminds me of one of those ghillie suits that snipers wear. I'm betting that it's because I vividly remember seeing him in an old issue of Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe as a kid and finding him interesting.  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  duckduckgoose Says:  
  2012-01-21 21:17:54  
  "She's headed for the George Washington bridge." If the wasp is a flying super hero, why does she need to take a bridge to get to New Jersey?  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  Dreaded Porcupine Says:  
  2012-04-12 20:22:15  
  Come on you got to love Porky. He has the most unique costume in all of comics. He looks like a walking haystack. A goblin. Cousin It from the Addmans Family. Great imagination for 1963 when he was created. All the villains were kind of cheesy back in those days. A very conservative time.  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  Webslinger Says:  
  2012-05-06 17:28:05  
  "Action follows fast and furious... sincerily Stan"... Really Stan??

Why would the Porcupine use his fantasy to just throw one pellet from I don't know what on our heroes, why Stan did Wasp so dumb? Why do I care, why do I read????
Why God, why?
And after all I learn that Giant Man can spinn like a tornado!!!!!!

Oh God, all the explanation on how Porc stops his fly... I bet: Someone wrote a letter: "The Porcupine, most ridiculous idea I ever saw!", and Stan thought: "I'll make an incredible story with this guy, only to disprove this!".
 
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  shaunhamill Says:  
  2012-05-16 12:11:50  
  Man, I think this is the first time we've seen a superhero fan club in a Marvel comic, isn't it? It's so weird that kids who love Giant Man dress up like people who tried to kill him.

Gotta love the way the Porcupine takes himself out in this one, as well as the way Hank Pym just sort of smiles and laughs off a man's probable death. This series is so weird.
 
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  Ice Says:  
  2012-07-30 00:29:31  
  This one was a hard one to rate! It's a totally average story, really. But, the whole "infiltrate the fan club" thing is so absolutely ridiculous, it's ingenious. That's worth a star, in and of itself. And, a couple of really bad writing/editing errors deserve to have a star scratched off. Giant Man goes from not being able to change his size, in fear of shattering his ankle, to changing size twice with no ill effects, in a matter of pages. And, Porcupine's suit shrunk with him. Unless he made it out of unstable molecules, for some reason, it should have stayed, while he shrunk to nothingness.

I do like the ending, though. Overall, it's a pretty ok story.
 
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  saschavikos Says:  
  2012-08-10 10:55:10  
  giant man lives in Jersey? Hmm...some later plot points with him and wasp just started to make sense.  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  jfpj1991 Says:  
  2012-08-17 14:11:54  
  That was such a stupid story. 'The supernatural is not evil'. How would you know Jan. Have you done extensive research on the supernatural?  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  Dark_Knight93 Says:  
  2012-09-15 18:32:47  
  Well after a few decent Giant-Man issues started to emerge, the last two bring him back down to being unbearable. I'm counting down the issue until I don't have to see his stories anymore. Hulk and Sub-Mariner will be a blessing compared to this.  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  chrisWhite Says:  
  2012-09-22 22:04:46  
  I'm with Ice, the infiltration of the fan club was admittedly brilliant despite the execution and everything else in this issue falling to pieces.  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  specialque Says:  
  2012-09-23 23:44:01  
  I wanted to like this one more than I did. The ending almost redeemed it, but then they suggested that Porky may come back, so...no.

That last Wasp story was pretty yawn-inducing. I don't blame him for ignoring it.
 
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  Encolpius Says:  
  2012-11-18 18:27:13  
  Maybe I'm strange, but I kind of like the Porcupine. It's an interesting concept and I'm looking forward to his inevitable return.

The Wasp backup is basically a remake of the Japanese film "Diamajin", which came out in 1966. I'm not sure how Stan came across the source material.
 
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  fragsel Says:  
  2012-11-18 23:25:24  
  @Encolpius I guess he didn't since this is 1964 issue.  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  ringsting Says:  
  2012-11-23 02:22:28  
  Crap as usual, I hated Ant Man I think I despise Giant Man..on top of that...short of the baby alien the Porcupine is the worst villain in the order  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  edgar987 Says:  
  2013-01-18 15:30:31  
  Just bad...very bad.  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  Robareid Says:  
  2013-02-18 09:59:27  
  "GIANT MAN! GIANT MAN! RAA, RAA, RAA!
GIANT MAN! GIANT MAN! BOO, HAA, HAA!"

What a song...
 
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  rebelmswar Says:  
  2013-03-25 16:48:09  
  The Human Wicker Basket shrinks to nothingness very Doomesque, wonder if Wicker Basket will be able to subjugate a microscopic democracy too.  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

Marvel Comments
  Ben Reilly Says:  
  2013-05-20 17:27:45  
  I'm going to comment before I read this issue that I won't like it. I'll delete this if I do.  
 
Comment Like
 
Marvel Comments

 
 
Comic Ads
Comic Ads
COLLECTIONS/REPRINTS
 
Buy Essential Ant-Man, Volume 1 Online
Buy Essential Ant-Man, Volume 1 Online
 
Comic Ads
Comic Ads
REVIEWS/SYNOPSIS/COMMENTS/SUGGESTIONS
Submit a Review, Comment, Synopsis, Issue Blurb, if this issue should be essential or not, or any suggestions regarding this issue. See the Site FAQ for quidelines on what to submit for each selection.

Marvel Comics Image
Marvel Comics Left Image



Marvel Comics Right Image
Marvel Comics Bottom
   
 
Home | The Order | My Comic Box | Updates Blog | Statistics/Leader Board | Members Login | Contact | Site Map

Copyright 2011 @ Travis Starnes - Images & Comics property of Marvel Comics.